A. O. H. CONVENTION NEARS THE CLOSE
The Butte Daily Post, Butte, 1910-09-13, p.3
Page image
Full page scan, 2,658 × 3,851 pixels. The insets below are the parts of this page that belong to the clipping; click one to jump to it on the page.
headlineHeadline
reportThe article, column 1 of 2
reportThe article, column 2 of 2
name as printed"O'Neill, James / Murphy, M. Goggin."
name as printed"James Murphy. Denis P. Kane,"
name as printed""JEREMIAH J. LYNCH, Chairman,"
name as printed"Carthy, M. Monahan, J. J. Lynch."
Summary
"(Continued From Page One.)" Coverage of the closing day of the Montana state AOH convention held in Butte, September 1910 — three months after the Centerville-degrees 107-candidate meeting (1910-06-09). Heavy block of formal resolutions, committee names, and ladies' auxiliary appointments. **Resolutions** (Hibernians; full text in transcription.md): the convention renews its allegiance to the church and "the great republic of the United States"; believes "in the complete and absolute independence of Ireland" and demands "unity of action among Irishmen everywhere"; congratulates the Gaelic league on its fight "for compulsory Irish in the national university"; commends the Ladies' auxiliary for 15 years' service; indorses the former national officers' part in "an alliance between the Irish and German societies"; thanks those who introduced Irish history into Montana's parochial schools; opposes national assessments beyond the constitution; thanks the Butte and Anaconda papers. Signed JEREMIAH J. LYNCH, Chairman; CHARLES REGAN, Secretary; T. J. M'CARTHY; JAMES GREELEY; J. J. GIBBONS. **Committees Named** by State President John J. O'Meara at yesterday afternoon's session (as printed): - Credentials — John Franey, D. O'Neil, M. Goggin, J. P. Graney, Tom Coberly, M. Lenahan. - Rules of order and business — J. J. O'Mahoney, Charles H. Gallagher, Ed Fitzpatrick, A. Mullarkey, Frank Fitzpatrick, T. J. McCarthy. - Official reports — Martin Durkan, Ed Devine, Charles H. Gallagher, A. Lavelle, T. J. Moran, John V. Dwyer, J. P. Graney. - Finance — T. P. Corcoran, M. Lenahan, James Hurley, W. G. Rowan, John Gribben, A. Mullarkey. - Resolutions — Thos. Regan, Jas. Greeley, J. P. Graney, J. J. Gibbons, T. J. McCarthy, M. Monahan, J. J. Lynch. - Organization — James Connolly, A. Mullarkey, T. J. Kelly, W. E. Rowan, M. J. Gavigan, P. P. Lehan, Rev. John Hennessy. - Business — James O'Kelly, J. P. Graney, Thomas Moran, Owen O'Neill, James Murphy, M. Goggin. - Military organization — T. J. Moran, J. J. Conway, P. Cregg, John P. Lane, M. Mullarkey. - Scholarship — Rev. M. J. Hannan, Peter Kellighan, J. M. Browne, J. H. O'Meara, Denis O'Neil, J. P. Graney, J. J. O'Mahoney. - Insurance — Thomas H. Gallagher, Dan Lynch, Ed Fitzpatrick, T. W. Grimes, Robert Meenan, A. Mullarkey. - **Irish history — Rev. M. J. Hannan, Owen Kelly, James Murphy, D. Kane, Martin Durkan, P. J. Graney.** - Grievances — P. O'Donnell, A. Lavelle, P. J. Kelly, J. J. McCarthy, John Meenan, A. Mullarkey. - Ladies' auxiliary — James Hurley, John Graney, J. J. Conway, Denis O'Neill, John P. Lane, J. P. Graney. - Press — Charles Gallagher, P. J. Sullivan, Thomas Coberly, A. Mullarkey. - **Abuse of Irish surnames — W. E. Rowan, James Murphy, Denis P. Kane, John Gribben, James O'Kelly, J. P. Graney.** The session ended at 4:30. The Irish history committee suggested a joint committee of Hibernians and ladies' auxiliary to confer "with text-book publishers so that the very best histories of Ireland should be used in the schools". **Ladies' auxiliary.** State president Mrs. J. D. Murphy (introduced by Mrs. Mary Minnie, Silver Bow county president) named eleven committees; the ladies' resolutions (signed by Margaret Gillick, chairman) thank Father Hannan, Mayor Nevin and Brother Mulcahy of The Butte Independent and deplore the death of Rev. Father English, ex-county chaplain. Mayor Nevin welcomed the ladies at Hibernia hall. Deer Lodge county's Daughters of Erin delegates are listed. **Dance at Gardens.** Floor committee: C. H. Gallagher, Walter Sewell, P. H. Kennedy, James Murphy, T. J. McCarthy. Reception: Dan Lynch, John Gribben, J. H. O'Meara, Anthony Lavelle, Thomas Moran. The report corrects the state secretary's name to Patrick H. Kenny, deputy county assessor. ARCHIVE SIGNIFICANCE. (a) The September 1910 state AOH convention in Butte — JJM (here as plain "James Murphy" on the Business, Irish history and Abuse of Irish surnames committees and the dance floor committee) appears alongside Charles H. Gallagher (multiple committees) and a JJM-Gallagher pairing on the Irish-history thread that the user filed under. The clipping prints the resolutions chairman as "JEREMIAH J. LYNCH" — confirming Judge J. J. Lynch's given name as Jeremiah, supporting consolidation with person_judge_jeremiah_j_lynch_butte_aoh. (b) The pre-1912 JJM is visible on a state-level committee here; this is the launch pad for his county-presidency election two years later.
In its time
Narrative
The Fourteenth Biennial Convention of the Ancient Order of Hibernians in Montana, meeting in Butte, adopts resolutions declaring allegiance to church and country, demanding the complete independence of Ireland, congratulating the Gaelic League on its fight over the national university, commending the Ladies' Auxiliary, and thanking those who introduced Irish history into Montana's parochial schools. State President John J. O'Meara names the convention committees — credentials, finance, resolutions, organization, insurance, press and others — while the Ladies' Auxiliary, with state president Mrs. J. C. Murphy, adopts its own resolutions thanking Father Hannan for his opening sermon, endorsing the Irish language, and designating The Butte Independent for the convention's official printing. [transcription partial; OCR heavily degraded, many names uncertain]
- “We believe in the complete and absolute independence of Ireland”
- “Realizing the importance to our race of spreading a knowledge of Irish history”
- “There are emigres present who hail from the banks of the Lee and the Shannon's shore”
AI-generated (claude-opus-5). Verify against the transcription before quoting.
People
- James Joseph "James J." Murphy (b. 1883 Ardgroom; d. 1938 LA)(as printed: James Murphy)role: state convention committee member · family confidence: 75 strong
Identification on context — James Murphy on the Business committee at the 1910 Butte state AOH convention is plausibly JJM (then chief sentinel of the Centerville division, three months later). Lump-rather-than-split bias applies. Could also be the OTHER James Murphy (= person_james_j_murphy_butte_died_1927); held to the JJM-Centerville person consistent with the user's filing.
- Judge J. J. Lynch (Silver Bow / Butte AOH)(as printed: JEREMIAH J. LYNCH)role: resolutions committee chairman · family confidence: 10 flag
CONFIRMS the given name Jeremiah for Judge J. J. Lynch of the JJM cluster — supports lumping with the separate Ballycrovane (Beara-born) Lynch record. Two-records rule still technically applies but this clipping is strong consolidation evidence. [The two records were merged 2026-10-03.]
- Charles H. Gallagher (b. c.1875 Ballina, Co. Mayo, Ireland; d. 28 Aug 1964 Butte, age 89; founder of Wiz-Way Stores; AOH state president)(as printed: Charles H. Gallagher)role: rules of order and official reports committee · family confidence: 0 not family
Not family: recurring Butte AOH figure. Printed-name match to his person record; moved from mentioned in the 2026-10-03 rescan. Earlier note: Multiple committee appointments — the senior Butte AOH presence here alongside JJM. JJM-Gallagher pairing on the Irish-history thread is what the user filed under.
- T. J. McCarthy (Silver Bow AOH)(as printed: T. J. McCarthy)role: rules of order and resolutions committee · family confidence: 0 not family
Not family: recurring Butte AOH figure. Printed-name match to his person record; moved from mentioned in the 2026-10-03 rescan.
- role: finance committee · family confidence: 0 not family
Not family: recurring Butte AOH figure. Printed-name match to his person record; moved from mentioned in the 2026-10-03 rescan.
- W. J. Sewell / Walter J. Sewell (Butte AOH)(as printed: Walter Sewell)role: dance floor committee · family confidence: 0 not family
- James Connolly (Butte AOH Division 1 officer; county treasurer 1912)(as printed: James Connolly)role: organization committee · family confidence: 0 not family
- John J. O'Meara (AOH state president of Montana to 1912; Centennial Brewing manager)(as printed: John J. O'Meara)role: state president presiding · family confidence: 0 not family
- John H. O'Meara (president, Robert Emmet Literary Association, Butte, 1914)(as printed: J. H. O'Meara)role: scholarship committee and dance reception · family confidence: 0 not family
- Thomas J. Moran (financial secretary, Silver Bow county AOH, 1912)(as printed: T. J. Moran)role: convention committees · family confidence: 0 not family
- James F. Hurley ('Jimmy Hurley' of the Hennessy store; AOH Division 2 recording secretary, 1909)(as printed: James Hurley)role: finance committee · family confidence: 0 not family
- P. J. Sullivan (treasurer, AOH Division 1, Butte, 1913)(as printed: P. J. Sullivan)role: press committee · family confidence: 0 not family
- P. J. Kelly (treasurer, AOH Division 3, Butte, 1913)(as printed: P. J. Kelly)role: grievances committee · family confidence: 0 not family
- Patrick H. Kenny (A. O. H. state secretary of Montana, 1910-1912; deputy county assessor)(as printed: Patrick H. Kenny)role: state secretary aoh · family confidence: 0 not family
- M. J. Gavigan (Michael Gavigan), Butte Hibernian reciter(as printed: M. J. Gavigan)role: organization committee · family confidence: 0 not family
- John Ferns (president, AOH Division 2, 1904; standing committee chairman, 1909)(as printed: John Ferns)role: dance door committee · family confidence: 0 not family
- Anthony Lavelle (Butte AOH; Division 2 sergeant-at-arms 1909; secretary of the 1922 St. Patrick's committee)(as printed: Anthony Lavelle)role: convention committees and dance reception · family confidence: 0 not family
- John Franey (vice president, AOH Division 2, Butte, 1909-1910)(as printed: John Franey)role: credentials committee · family confidence: 0 not family
- Dennis O'Neill (Butte AOH, 1904-1912)(as printed: Denis O'Neil)role: convention committees · family confidence: 0 not family
- Dan Lynch (Butte AOH, 1910-1920)(as printed: Dan Lynch)role: insurance committee · family confidence: 0 not family
- James B. Mulcahy (managing editor, The Butte Independent)(as printed: Brother Mulcahy)role: managing editor butte independent thanked · family confidence: 0 not family
- Edward Fitzpatrick (Ed Fitzpatrick), Silver Bow county president of the AOH, 1919(as printed: Ed Fitzpatrick)role: convention committees · family confidence: 0 not family
- Maurice Goggins (Goggin), Butte AOH, 1910-1912(as printed: Maurice Goggin)role: convention committees and dance door · family confidence: 0 not family
- Rev. M. J. Hannan (pastor of St. Mary's, Butte; Irish Relief Committee 1916-17)(as printed: Rev. M. J. Hannan)role: scholarship and irish history committees · family confidence: 0 not family
- Charles P. Nevin (mayor of Butte 1910; Democratic county chairman 1924)(as printed: Mayor Nevin)role: mayor welcomed ladies auxiliary · family confidence: 0 not family
- John V. Dwyer (assistant / deputy county attorney of Silver Bow, 1910-1913)(as printed: John V. Dwyer)role: official reports committee · family confidence: 0 not family
- Mrs. Mamie Lenahan (Lenihan), Ladies' Auxiliary AOH, Butte Division 1; state secretary(as printed: Mamie Lenahan)role: auditing committee ladies auxiliary · family confidence: 0 not family
- Mrs. Margaret Kiley (Kiely), Ladies' Auxiliary AOH; state treasurer 1916-1921(as printed: Margaret Kiely)role: ladies auxiliary convention committees · family confidence: 0 not family
- Mrs. Mamie Melia (Ladies' Auxiliary AOH, Butte, 1910-1920)(as printed: Mamie Melia)role: ladies auxiliary convention committees · family confidence: 0 not family
Also mentioned
- Charles Regan · resolutions_committee_secretary
- James Greeley · resolutions_committee
- J. J. Gibbons · resolutions_committee
- Denis P. Kane · abuse_of_irish_surnames_committee
- Rev. John Hennessy · organization_committee
Places
- Butte, Montana (primary)
Themes
Story threads
Tags
Source type
news_item, public_meeting_report, list_of_officers
Related sources
- 1910-06-09 — The Butte Daily Post, p.3 — MORE THAN HUNDRED CANDIDATES
- 1911-06-13 — The Butte Daily Post, p.2 — IRISH-AMERICAN BALL A SUCCESS
- 1912-10-14 — The Butte Miner, p.6 — HIBERNIANS CHOOSE OFFICERS AT MEETING / James J. Murphy Heads the Organization for the Ensuing Term.
- 1921-08-10 — The Butte Miner, p.7 — Ancient Order Hibernians and Auxiliary Order Meet in Annual State Assembly
Transcription
Dotted underlines mark key terms on first mention — hover or tab to one for a reference note. The wording is the source’s own.
Open questions
- The page prints the committee as "Irish history" (Rev. M. J. Hannan, Owen Kelly, James Murphy, D. Kane, Martin Durkan, P. J. Graney; the text-book suggestion came from it); "Aims of Irish substance" was an OCR error, and the page also has a separate "Abuse of Irish surnames" committee with James Murphy and John Gribben. Still open is whether this plain "James Murphy" is JJM rather than another James Murphy.
- The JEREMIAH J. LYNCH signature on the resolutions confirms Judge Lynch's given name. Consider consolidating person_judge_jeremiah_j_lynch_butte_aoh and Judge J. J. Lynch references into the single Jeremiah record on a future back-pass.