MORE THAN HUNDRED CANDIDATES
The Butte Daily Post, Butte, 1910-06-09, p.3
Page image
Full page scan, 2,661 × 3,847 pixels. The insets below are the parts of this page that belong to the clipping; click one to jump to it on the page.
headlineHeadline
articleThe article as printed
name as printed"Murphy, Pat Lee, Con J. Murphy, James"
name as printed"James J. Murphy was chief sentinel."
Summary
Sub-heads: "DEGREES CONFERRED UPON A BIG CLASS BY CENTERVILLE HIBERNIANS / ENJOY INTERESTING PROGRAM / T. J. M'Carthy Presides — Social Session Follows." A very large meeting of the Centerville Hibernians the previous evening (Wed 8 Jun 1910) at their hall for first/second/third degree conferrals. 107 candidates initiated. AOH officer slate active at this meeting: - County President — T. J. McCarthy (presiding) - Degree-conferring team — T. J. McCarthy, M. J. Gavigan, P. H. Kenny, John V. Dwyer (Assistant County Attorney) - Chief of escorts — T. J. Moran (secretary) - Guards — James Connolly, John Murphy, Pat Lee, Con J. Murphy, James Doolin, Mike Murphy, Peter Shannon, Ed Lawlor - **Chief sentinel — James J. Murphy** Programme: Address J. B. Mulcahy; recitation Michael Gavigan; address Jerry D. Murphy; song John Murphy; address Thomas Keeley; song Frank Laird; address P. H. Kenny; song Thomas Grimes; address John V. Dwyer. Closing: entire audience singing "God Save Ireland." ARCHIVE SIGNIFICANCE. Anchor for the JJM-Centerville-AOH career arc — June 1910 = chief sentinel under county president T. J. McCarthy. Two and a half years later (Oct 1912) JJM is himself elected county president. This establishes the upward trajectory. Also: John V. Dwyer (Assistant County Attorney) is a recurring Butte AOH figure who appears again in the 1922 St Patrick's banquet attendee list (born Michigan there). DWYER surname is the same as the 1918 Kilcatherine drowning victims who were JJM's cousins. Worth tracing whether Asst. County Attorney John V. Dwyer of Butte is related.
In its time
Narrative
The Hibernians of Centerville fill their hall for the conferring of first, second and third degrees on 107 candidates, with County President T. J. McCarthy, M. J. Gavigan, P. H. Kenny and Assistant County Attorney John V. Dwyer officiating. T. J. Moran served as chief of escorts, James J. Murphy as chief sentinel, and guards included James Connolly, John Murphy, Pat Lee, Con J. Murphy, James Doolin, Mike Murphy, Peter Shannon and Ed Lawlor. A social session followed with addresses by J. B. Mulcahy, Jerry D. Murphy, Thomas Keeley, P. H. Kenny and Dwyer, a recitation by Michael Gavigan, and songs from John Murphy, Frank Laird and Thomas Grimes.
- “The ceremonies were concluded by the singing, in which the entire audience joined, of "God Save Ireland."”
- “There were 107 candidates for degrees.”
AI-generated (claude-opus-5). Verify against the transcription before quoting.
People
- James Joseph "James J." Murphy (b. 1883 Ardgroom; d. 1938 LA)(as printed: James J. Murphy)role: chief sentinel · family confidence: 50 candidate
Family confidence aligned with identity confidence 60 on 4 Oct 2026; the reason is in identity_basis.
- T. J. McCarthy (Silver Bow AOH)(as printed: T. J. McCarthy)role: county president presiding · family confidence: 0 not family
Not family: recurring Butte AOH figure. Printed-name match to his person record; moved from mentioned in the 2026-10-03 rescan. Earlier note: Predecessor to JJM as Silver Bow County AOH president; same T. J. McCarthy who later attends the 1922 St. Patrick's banquet as 'T. J. McCarthy, Cork, Ireland'.
- James Connolly (Butte AOH Division 1 officer; county treasurer 1912)(as printed: James Connolly)role: guard · family confidence: 0 not family
- Thomas J. Moran (financial secretary, Silver Bow county AOH, 1912)(as printed: T. J. Moran)role: chief of escorts and secretary · family confidence: 0 not family
- Ed Lawler (Edward Lawlor), vice president of the Silver Bow county AOH, 1912(as printed: Ed Lawlor)role: guard · family confidence: 0 not family
- Con J. Murphy (Butte AOH Division 1)(as printed: Con J. Murphy)role: guard · family confidence: 0 not family
- Peter Shannon (Butte AOH Division 1)(as printed: Peter Shannon)role: guard · family confidence: 0 not family
- Patrick H. Kenny (A. O. H. state secretary of Montana, 1910-1912; deputy county assessor)(as printed: P. H. Kenny)role: degree conferrer · family confidence: 0 not family
- M. J. Gavigan (Michael Gavigan), Butte Hibernian reciter(as printed: M. J. Gavigan)role: degree conferrer · family confidence: 0 not family
- James B. Mulcahy (managing editor, The Butte Independent)(as printed: J. B. Mulcahy)role: speaker · family confidence: 0 not family
- John V. Dwyer (assistant / deputy county attorney of Silver Bow, 1910-1913)(as printed: John V. Dwyer)role: assistant county attorney and degree conferrer · family confidence: 0 not family
- Jerry D. Murphy (Centerville; president of the Centerville Young Men's Club, 1912)(as printed: Jerry D. Murphy)role: speaker · family confidence: 0 not family
Also mentioned
- John Murphy · guard_and_song_performer
- Pat Lee · guard
- James Doolin · guard
- Mike Murphy · guard
Same as the Michael in Tady's 8 Butte-emigrant children list (1992 letter)? Possible identification.
- Thomas Keeley · speaker
- Frank Laird · song_performer
- Thomas Grimes · song_performer
Places
- Butte, Montana (primary)
- Centerville (district of Butte) (primary)
Themes
Story threads
Tags
Source type
news_item, public_meeting_report, list_of_officers
Related sources
- 1912-10-14 — The Butte Miner, p.6 — HIBERNIANS CHOOSE OFFICERS AT MEETING / James J. Murphy Heads the Organization for the Ensuing Term.
- 1912-10-14 — The Butte Daily Post, p.7 — JAMES J. MURPHY IS COUNTY PRESIDENT OF THE HIBERNIANS
- 1913-01-09 — The Anaconda Standard, p.11 — JOINT INSTALLATION HELD BY HIBERNIANS
- 1922-03-17 — The Anaconda Standard, p.8 — Those Who Attended.
- 1992-05-29 — The Montana Standard, p.4 — Tracing Murphys back to Ireland
Transcription
Dotted underlines mark key terms on first mention — hover or tab to one for a reference note. The wording is the source’s own.
Open questions
- Three of the named guards (Con J. Murphy, Mike Murphy, John Murphy) and one of the speakers (Jerry D. Murphy) could be matches for the four MALE Butte-emigrant children of Tady Murphy (Michael, Dan, Johney, Cornelius, Jerry — five of the eight). Worth a cross-check pass — each candidate-name should get a tentative person record with the Tady-tree alignment flagged.
- John V. Dwyer Asst. County Attorney 1910 — kinship to the 1918 Kilcatherine drowning Dwyers worth tracing.
- Masthead question — clip header reads "THE BUTTE INTER" but Newspapers.com files this under Butte Daily Post.