Mullaney to Agnes Kelly Murphy, Jan 25-27 (c.1925-29) — Walkerville; thanks for buffalo robe and magnifying glass; mentions Melda, Maggie, Jen, Winifred
Family letters — Michael R. Mullaney to Agnes Kelly Murphy · private family correspondence (later digitized into docx form by descendant) · c1925-1929-01-25
date confidence: estimated
Summary
Personal letter from **Cousin Mike Mullaney** (Walkerville) to **Agnes Kelly Murphy** (wife of the user's JJM, James J. Murphy, d. Los Angeles 1938) — same writer- and-recipient pair as the March 31/25 letter, but written Jan 25-26-27 of an unspecified year. ## DATE BOUNDS Header reads only "Walkerville January 25/26" — no year. Most plausibly **1925, 1926, 1927, 1928, or early 1929**. Mike died 19 May 1929 so this letter precedes his death. Internal clues: - References Christmas presents Mike received Dec 24 (preceding the Jan letter date) - Mentions **Melda** sending him a nightgown gift — Melda could be Imelda Murphy (JJM Sr's daughter, b. ~1920) but she'd be too young (4-8 in 1924-28) to be sending nightgown gifts independently. OR Melda could be a different relative. - Mentions **Maggie** received a scrap-paper note in a bundle of newspapers — Maggie could be Margaret (JJM's sister of the 1912 obit), or Maggie Devitt (Mike's BC sister) - **Jen** is in regular correspondence (still requiring doctor's service, but steadily employed) - **Winifred** has not written; Mike owes her a reply Given the relative-list overlap with the March 31/25 letter (Nellie, Aunt Agnes Brennan implied, "the Murphys" as a family unit), MOST plausibly this letter is **January 1925** — the same Christmas-1924 / January-1925 timeframe as the March 31/25 reference to events of the same winter. ## KEY CONTENTS Thank-you-and-news letter: - **Buffalo robe gift "from all the Murphys"** (the Murphy family collectively sent Mike a buffalo robe / lap blanket for Christmas; Mike had been wanting one for 5-6 years). Mike uses it where he retires — calls it his "buffalo." - **Glass of very good magnifying power + sunglass** from Agnes ("can set fire to anything, from a house to a haystack, when sun is shining and glass properly focused") - **Nightgown** from Melda - The Murphys' card said "From all the Murphys" — suggests the JJM family (James J. Murphy, d. LA 1938) was collectively named on a gift card to Cousin Mike c. Christmas 1924 - Mike was at the P.O. Dec 24 and again Dec 28 - Mike's office colleague **Miss Boulton** — adds a Mullaney workplace context - Mike writes "I clap it on where I retire" — suggests he has a desk job at this point (not strictly a miner; or semi-retired) - Mike has been promising himself a stint at the **Holland rink** before the ice melts — eyes too sensitive to bright light for skating - Mild winter through January; 5-6 inches snow lately; snow remains as "complete white blanket" ## CLOSING "I will close with love and good wishes for you, Jim, and all the family. Cousin Mike. North Fourth St. Walkerville Mont." - "Jim" = Agnes Kelly Murphy's husband = James J. Murphy (b. 1883 Ardgroom; d. Los Angeles 17 Dec 1938). He was alive throughout 1925-1929, so his mention does not narrow the date. The bound stays Jan 1925 to Jan 1929 (Mike died 19 May 1929). Most plausibly **January 1925** matching the March 31/25 letter context. Held as estimated 1925-01-25.
In its time
People
- Michael R. Mullaney (b. ~1856 Michigan; d. 19 May 1929 Walkerville; Chatham cousin; letter-writer)(as printed: Cousin Mike)role: writer · family confidence: 95 certain
- Agnes Kelly Murphy(as printed: My Dear Agnes)role: recipient · family confidence: 95 certain
- James Joseph "James J." Murphy (b. 1883 Ardgroom; d. 1938 LA)(as printed: Jim [Murphy])role: recipients husband · family confidence: 95 certain
The recipient's husband: Agnes Kelly Murphy was married to James J. Murphy (m. 1908; d. Los Angeles 1938). The earlier note here took him for the James J. Murphy who died in Butte in 1927, under the framework retired on 2026-05-27. Linked in the 2026-10-03 rescan; was under mentioned.
Also mentioned
- the Murphys (collective) · gift_card_signatories_buffalo_robe
The Murphy family collectively signed a Christmas gift-card to Mike, sending a buffalo robe.
- Melda · gift_giver_nightgown
Sent Mike a nightgown for Christmas. Most plausibly = Imelda Murphy (JJM Sr's daughter, b. ~1920 → would be a young child at the c.1925-1929 letter; possible if Imelda was named on the gift card without independent agency) OR a different Melda in the cluster.
- Maggie · family_member_received_scrap_paper
Mike included a scrap of paper for Maggie in a bundle of newspapers. Could be Margaret Murphy (PJM's sister of 1912 obit), Maggie Devitt (Mike's BC sister), or another Maggie.
- Jen · regular_correspondent
Still requires doctor's service but steadily employed. Mike owes her a reply.
- Winifred · unanswered_correspondent
- Sister · christmas_card_sender
Mike received a Christmas card from his (unnamed) sister; could be Maggie Devitt or another sister.
- Miss Boulton · mikes_office_colleague
Mike's office colleague who asked who sent his Christmas package. Adds the workplace-context detail.
Places
- Walkerville, Montana (primary)
- Butte, Montana (primary)
- Silver Bow County, Montana (primary)
Themes
Story threads
Tags
Related sources
- 1929-05-20 — The Montana Standard, p.7 — OLD-TIME BUTTE RESIDENT PASSES — Michael Mullaney Dies at Walkerville; Funeral Not Arranged
- 1925-03-31 — Family letters — Michael R. Mullaney to Agnes Kelly Murphy — Mullaney to Agnes Kelly Murphy, 31 Mar 1925 — Walkerville; reports tragic death of nephew Jimmie; mentions Aunt Agnes Brennan, Nellie Dennison, Maggie Devitt of Crofton BC
- c1916 — Family papers — Michael R. Mullaney verse manuscripts — Mullaney verse: 'Sixty Years' (c.1916) + 'Seventy Years' (c.1926) — bachelor-cousin meditations on mortality
Transcription
Dotted underlines mark key terms on first mention — hover or tab to one for a reference note. The wording is the source’s own.
Open questions
- Exact year — most plausibly January 1925 matching the March 31/25 letter context. Could be 1925, 1926, 1927, 1928, or Jan 1929. Internal weather references could cross-check against historical Butte January weather records.
- Identity of "Melda" — Imelda Murphy (JJM Sr's daughter) or a different relative? Possibly a Mullaney/Chatham cousin's daughter.
- Identity of "Jen" — a Mullaney sibling or Chatham cousin in regular correspondence with Mike.