Annals of Beara Vol II, p.412: JOHNNY O'DWYER & ELLEN LYNCH (CAOLRUA) — 14 children incl. Robert (1918 Pointe Ranna drowning victim, IRA Ballycrovane Co. captain) + the 1921 Black-and-Tans house-burning during the War of Independence
Riobárd Ó Dwyer, "Who Were My Ancestors? Annals of Beara," Volume II · Beara peninsula, Co. Cork, Ireland
date confidence: undated_reference_book
Summary
Dwyer family genealogy page. The O'Dwyers of Caolrua are cousin-adjacent to our Murphy line — the 1918 Pointe Ranna fishing-boat drowning that killed Robert O'Dwyer also killed John Murphy + Patie Murphy (Jim Murphy + Julia O'Sullivan's sons per p.270 section C), and JJM's own cousins Robert + Richard Dwyer (already documented in the archive as person_robert_dwyer_kilcatherine_1918 + person_richard_dwyer_kilcatherine_1918). This page is the **primary-source narrative** for the Kilcatherine/Pointe Ranna context that appears across multiple archive records. Key biographical detail on the O'Dwyer family (Johnny + Ellen had 14 children, 2 died at birth, 12 survived): - (1) **Robert (Oct 22 1893)** — "six feet and a half inch tall... very promising athlete... held the Cork County Senior 100 yards champion Pat Flanagan of Castletownbere to a draw at Eyeries sports... weight-thrower and hop- step and jumper. However, he was one of five men drowned off Pointe Ranna, Fay, Kilcatherine, on the night of Nov. 12th 1918, when coming back from seine fishing. Robert, who was then only 25 years of age, was **Captain of the Ballycrovane Company of the I.R.A.**" - The other four drowned with him: Sean (a Chaoil) O'Sullivan (father of Denny O'Sullivan, Caolrua), Jer (Murt) McCarthy of Faunkil, and **Dan Murphy's two brothers John and Patie Murphy of Ballycrovane** (= the John Dec 1891 and Patie Apr 1895 listed in Annals p.270 section C as Jim Murphy + Julia O'Sullivan's sons) - Patie Healy of Faunkil survived - (2) Annie (Oct 12 1894) — about to be professed a Nun but had to leave the Convent after the **Black and Tans burned the house in Caolrua during "the time of the trouble" in 1921**. Father Johnny d. 28 Jun 1920 age 72; mother Ellen d. 4 Mar 1921 age 48 after being unconscious for four days following night-after-night Black-and-Tans raids - (3) Liam (Jan 9 1896) — **Commandant of the Beara Battalion, West Cork Brigade**, during the War of Independence. Author later of "Beara in Irish History." Went to USA Aug 1926, returned 1935 to build a house + shop + dance hall in Ardgroom Village ("The Cross") - Multiple later children emigrated to Butte, Montana — a continuation of the Cork-to-Butte chain into the next generation: Tim (Aug 5 1899) → Butte 1924 m. Nellie O'Rahilly (whose father Jim O'Rahilly had also gone Butte → m. Kate Jer O'Sullivan of Reenavaude); Pat (Apr 5 1901) → Butte 1923 + Eureka lead mine UT + Silver King Park City + Bingham UT open-cut copper + Port Angeles Dam + San Francisco 1926-1930 (Championship of California stepdancing 1927) → returned Butte 1930 → NY → m. Ann O'Sullivan (Corneenach); Richie/Dick (Jan 3 1903) → Calumet Mines MI 1925 → Butte → San Francisco → NY m. Tess Moloney; Mike (Jan 19 1906) → Detroit → NY → US Army WWII Texas The entire Caolrua O'Dwyer family is a parallel Beara → Butte migration story tightly entangled with our Murphy line via: (a) the 1918 Pointe Ranna joint-drowning event, (b) the IRA / Ballycrovane Company / War of Independence context that our cousins lived through, and (c) the multi-decade Beara-to-Butte chain migration that continued from the 1880s (our Pat) through the 1920s (Tim/Pat/Richie O'Dwyer).
People
- role: name clash with butte press robert dwyer · family confidence: 0 not family
**REVISED 2026-05-29 per user + Oliver correction.** The Annals' Robert O'Dwyer of Caolrua (IRA Ballycrovane Company Captain, age 25, son of Johnny O'Dwyer + Ellen Lynch) is almost certainly NOT the "Robert Dwyer cousin of JJM" the 1918 Butte press reported. The 1918 Butte attribution came via a trans-Atlantic letter from Cork to James M. McCarthy of Centennial Brewing and conflated victim surnames. The actual JJM-Beara connections among the 5 victims are the **Murphy** victims John + Patie of Ballycrovane (sons of Jim Murphy + Julia O'Sullivan per Annals p.270 section C), who appear in the 1918 Butte press misattributed as "Robert Dwyer" and "Richard Dwyer." The person_robert_dwyer_kilcatherine_1918 record is preserved as historical claim-documentation only.
- Jack Sullivan (= Sean a' Choill O'Sullivan of Caolrua, Kilcatherine, c. 1859-1918; drowned 12 Nov 1918)(as printed: Sean (a Chaoil) O'Sullivan)role: 1918 pointe ranna drowning victim · family confidence: 0 not family
- John Murphy (Ballycrovane, 1891–1918; drowned off Pointe Ranna; James's first cousin)(as printed: John Murphy + Patie Murphy (Jim Murphy + Julia O'Sullivan's sons of Ballycrovane))role: 1918 pointe ranna drowning victims · family confidence: 95 certain
- Patie (Patrick) Murphy (Ballycrovane, 1895–1918; drowned with his brother John; James's first cousin)(as printed: Patie Murphy)role: 1918 pointe ranna drowning victims · family confidence: 95 certain
Also mentioned
- Johnny O'Dwyer + Ellen Lynch (Caolrua) · section_b_parents
- Jer (Murt) McCarthy of Faunkil · 1918_pointe_ranna_drowning_victim
- Patie Healy of Faunkil · 1918_pointe_ranna_drowning_survivor
Brother of Johnny Healy; survived the drowning but didn't live long afterwards.
- Liam O'Dwyer (Jan 9 1896) · ira_beara_battalion_commandant
Author of 'Beara in Irish History.' Returned 1935 from US to build a house + shop + dance hall in Ardgroom Village (The Cross).
- Annie O'Dwyer (Oct 12 1894) · convent_returnee_after_1921_raid
Places
- Kilcatherine (parish) (primary)
- Ballycrovane (primary)
- Butte, Montana (secondary)
Themes
Story threads
Tags
Related sources
- undated — Riobárd Ó Dwyer, "Who Were My Ancestors? Annals of Beara," Volume II — Annals of Beara Vol II, p.413: Caolrua O'Dwyer family continued — Pat O'Dwyer Butte mining career 1923-1930 + Mike O'Dwyer US Army WWII + (C) JOHN O'DWYER & KATHLEEN MCCARTHY next generation
- undated — Riobárd Ó Dwyer, "Who Were My Ancestors? Annals of Beara," Volume II — Annals of Beara Vol II, p.270 sections (A)-(C): Patrick Murphy of Ballycrovane → Seamus Mór Murphy + Peig Uonhi → Jim Murphy + Julia O'Sullivan (Seer)
- 1918-12-10 — The Anaconda Standard, p.7 — ONLY ONE SURVIVES IN PARTY OF SIX
Transcription
Dotted underlines mark key terms on first mention — hover or tab to one for a reference note. The wording is the source’s own.