The seanchaí's account of the Ballycrovane follower lost in November 1918, in Emma Verling's translation from 'Gort Broc'

Emma Verling's English translation of Martin's "Gort Broc" (Badger's Field), story 102, "The Sinking of the Béal a' Chrobháin Follower" · private email to Luke Murphy, 10 Jan 2025 (Gmail message 19451d9684a3fc99, subject "11 Nov 1918 Drowning") · 2025-01-10

oral historyprimary focus

Summary

A first-hand storyteller's account ("That happened during my lifetime"), from the Irish-language book "Gort Broc", of the loss of the follower of the Béal a' Chrobháin (Ballycrovane) seine in November 1918 ("around Lá 'le Michíl in November"). The crew went out at nightfall to Kenmare River or under Cuailleach, found no fish, came in at midnight, and against the seine master's advice went out again for the low tide an hour before dawn. Returning at daybreak the follower cut inside "a horrible, dangerous submerged reef"; its steersman, a man with the use of one hand who "had more experience of a horse and cart", ran her onto it, the reef "erupted and threw the boat up in the air", and she came down in planks. Only the weakest boy, clinging to an oar, was taken up by the second seine boat. A diver came from Cork city and found nobody; three bodies came ashore on a big strand a week later and three more three weeks later in a ravine among the seaweed. "There were two brothers of the Ó Murchú family among them. There was a man of the Ó Súilleabháin family there, and he left six children and his wife behind, and a boy of the Mac Cárthaigh family." (The storyteller's six drowned and one saved differs from the five drowned given by Riobard Ó Dwyer and the Annals; Emma's covering email identifies the survivor as Pete Healy and the rescuer as Maurice Harrington, Cáipí.) The two Ó Murchú brothers are John (b. 2 Dec 1891) and Patie (b. 5 Apr 1895) Murphy of Ballycrovane, sons of Jim Murphy and Julia O'Sullivan (Seer), cousins of James J. Murphy of Butte per the Butte Independent of 14 Dec 1918. See research/docs/beara-kin-thread-2026-09-26.md.

People

Also mentioned

  • two brothers of the Ó Murchú family · drowned_murphy_brothers

    John and Patie Murphy of Ballycrovane (Annals II p. 270 C).

  • a boy of the Mac Cárthaigh family · drowned

    Jer (Murt) McCarthy of Faunkil.

  • the seine master (did not go out) · survivor_by_absence
  • the boy who was in the follower · sole_survivor

    Patie Healy of Faunkil, who died some months later (Annals II p. 412; Emma Verling).

Places

Themes

Story threads

Tags

Related sources

Transcription
transcription: complete · confidence high
--- source: For Luke.docx (Emma Verling, 10 Jan 2025) --- For Luke 102. The Sinking of the Béal a’ Chrobháin Follower (fonota 3 after ‘Follower’) Here’s a story about danger at sea. A lot of people lost their lives on the sea bed. God bless and rest their souls. I’ll tell you about local seine fishermen in my own townland whom I knew well, who were drowned. Also, I am familiar with the place where it happened. One night, a seine crew went fishing from Béal a’ Chrobháin. We called them the Béal a’ Chrobháin seine, and they were usually fishing in Kenmare River or under Cuailleach. They went there at nightfall. Fish weren’t seen and couldn’t be fished, so they returned at midnight, put their boat on its stand and agreed that the night was very long. It was around Lá ’le Michíl in November, I remember it well. They agreed that it would be a good idea to try again at dawn because a low tide was coming one hour before daybreak, and the fish usually ran then, so they couldn’t miss that opportunity. The seine master didn’t agree, because he said they often did that, and had nothing to show for it. But the other fishermen disagreed. They came to the shore at the appointed time, every one of them, except the seine master. They went into the boats and rowed until they went to where the fish usually were, but there was no fish there on that night. That didn’t please them at all. They arrived at the time appointed, all except the seine master because he didn’t expect that any fish would be there. Before they went out, the other seines had taken a small amout of fish. I remember the night well. It was a fine, calm night but there were shores that weren’t too high, but a change was coming and that was the one danger that existed. When day was dawning, they knew that it was pointless searching for fish. They faced the boats towards home and they were hurrying along. There were other seines there also and they were rowing along together. There were two seine boats there in all. The follower was beside its own seine boat, and she went towards land where there was a horrible, dangerous submerged reef. The man on the rudder, didn’t have very much experience of the sea, he had more experience of a horse and cart on the road, but he used to go seining too. He wasn’t very good on oars, because he had only the use of one hand, may God bless his soul. He was put on the rudder, steering the boat, and he ran the boat into the dangerous reef, the reef erupted and threw the boat up in the air. I don’t know how high, but high enough, because it was a bad reef. When the boat fell down, it was broken into planks on the surface of the water, and every man was thrown into the water, except for one boy who couldn’t swim or row. He was the weakest boy of the crew, but he stayed on the surface of the water. The other seine was behind them and when they approached the place, they heard someone’s voice, but they didn’t see any boat. They didn’t go in towards the reef, because they feared it. They couldn’t come in close to them, but the seine boat went around the reef to see if there was any sighting of the men. There wasn’t, because the boat was broken into planks and the oars were floating on the surface of the water. The other seine boat came upon them, and they went in the direction of the planks, but they didn’t see any man clinging to an oar or a plank, or a keel. They couldn’t find them at all. They heard a voice in the water a short distance from them and went towards it, and who was there, clutching an oar, but the boy who was in the follower. He had been removed from the long boat to steer the follower instead of their master, who had steered it before that. He spoke to them. “I’m here, won’t you take me in?” he said. He was entangled in an oar. They took him into the boat, and that was the only crew member they found. They went ashore when they failed to find anybody else, and it was broad daylight. On the following day, the story spread that the boat had sunk, and, indeed, it was a great cause of distress to everyone, especially to their fathers and mothers. People who heard it went to nearby shores but it was no use, they saw none of the crew, and they couldn’t be found. They sent to Cork city for a diver and he came and dived down to search for the men, but that was fruitless. Not one of them was found, and the diver had to give up. When day broke, indeed, everybody heard it. A week after that, three fishermen were washed up on the shore in a big strand, and three weeks later, the other three were found in a lower strand, inside in a ravine among the seaweed, may God rest them. They were buried. That happened during my lifetime. There were two brothers of the Ó Murchú family among them. There was a man of the Ó Súilleabháin family there, and he left six children and his wife behind, and a boy of the Mac Cárthaigh family. Source: Badger’s Field translation of Gort Broc by Emma Verling

Dotted underlines mark key terms on first mention — hover or tab to one for a reference note. The wording is the source’s own.

Source ID: 2025-01-10_emma-verling-translation_gort-broc-sinking-of-the-beal-a-chrobhain-follower

Reference: Rights: Emma Verling's own translation, sent "For Luke"; her book of the translation was launched in September 2026 (her email of 24 Sept 2026). Do not publish or quote at length without her permission. Downloaded and filed 26 Sept 2026 with the user's consent.

Accessed by lukedmurphy on 2025-01-10.