JJM Sr's civil birth cert — born 2 Aug 1883 Ardgroom; father Patrick Murphy SHOEMAKER; mother Ellen Murphy formerly Lyne
Republic of Ireland Civil Registration — Birth Register · Birth Registered in the district of Kilcatherine, Superintendent Registrar's District of Castletown, Co. Cork · 1883-08-02
Document image
The scan of the original record, as filed in the archive. Zoom in to read it against the transcription below.
Summary
Republic of Ireland Civil Registration Birth Certificate (reproduction issued 8 November 2013 by Helen Foley, Authorised Officer) transcribing the original 1883 register entry. Entry No. **168**, registered 10 August 1883 in the Superintendent Registrar's District of Castletown, Co. Cork, birth-registration district of Kilcatherine. Registration No. **11054628**. - **Date of Birth: 2 August 1883** - Place of Birth: **Ardgroom** - Name: **James** - Sex: Male - Father: **Patrick Murphy, Shoemaker, of Ardgroom** - Mother: **Ellen Murphy formerly Lyne** (Ardgroom) - Informant: **Dora Neill**, "Present at the Birth, Ardgroom" - When Registered: 10 August 1883 - Registrar: **Charles Harrison** (same registrar as the 1881 Patrick Murphy + Ellen Lyne marriage cert — continuing civil-registry service in Kilcatherine district) **CRITICAL DATE DISCREPANCY**: The 1971 baptismal-cert reproduction (already filed at 1883-07-26_eyeries-co-cork_james-joseph-murphy-baptism) states born **26 July 1883**, baptized **29 July 1883**. This civil cert states born **2 August 1883**. Both are primary-source transcripts of contemporaneous 1883 records (the parish baptismal register + the state birth register respectively). Reconciliation: baptism on 29 July 1883 BEFORE birth on 2 August 1883 is physically impossible. So either (a) the baptismal-cert's "26 July" was a 1971-era transcription error from the parish register, or (b) the civil cert's "2 August" was a registrar error. Most likely (a) — civil registration was filed 8 days after birth (10 Aug regs from 2 Aug birth) with Dora Neill, present at the birth, as informant, while the 1971 baptismal cert was a retrospective extract by a different cleric 88 years after the event. The CIVIL CERT IS LIKELY AUTHORITATIVE; the baptism cert's dates need re-verification against the original parish register. **Patrick's occupation = SHOEMAKER** (specific trade) — the 1881 marriage cert had recorded him as "Tradesman" (generic). Shoemaker is the specific kind of tradesman he was. **Ellen "formerly Lyne"** — the FOURTH primary-source confirmation of Ellen's maiden name as Lyne (after the 1881 marriage cert, the 1883 baptismal cert, the 1936 Daniel L Murphy marriage license). **Dora Neill** "Present at the Birth" — likely the midwife who attended Ellen's delivery. NEW name to the archive.
In its time
Parties named in the record
- registered child
born: 1883-08-02
- fatherPatrick Murphy(= Patrick "Pat" J. Murphy (Cork-born bartender / shoemaker; d. 1912 Warm Springs MT))100
occupation: Shoe-maker · residence: Ardgroom
- motherEllen Murphy formerly Lyne(= Ellen (Lyne) Murphy (b. Ardgroom; m. Patrick Murphy 1881; d. Butte 1935))100
residence: Ardgroom
People — link detail
- James Joseph "James J." Murphy (b. 1883 Ardgroom; d. 1938 LA)(as printed: James)role: registered child · family confidence: 100 certain
born: 1883-08-02
The user's JJM. Birth date 2 August 1883 per the civil register; baptism cert states 26 July 1883 — the discrepancy noted in summary. Civil cert is more authoritative; the JJM person record's birth date should be updated to 1883-08-02 and the 1883-07-26 reading flagged as a baptism- cert transcription error.
- Patrick "Pat" J. Murphy (Cork-born bartender / shoemaker; d. 1912 Warm Springs MT)(as printed: Patrick Murphy)role: father · family confidence: 100 certain
occupation: Shoe-maker · residence: Ardgroom
OCCUPATION = SHOEMAKER per this 1883 birth cert (specific trade). The 1881 Pat-Ellen marriage cert had recorded "Tradesman" (generic). Shoemaker fits — a leather-trade Eyeries-area artisan. Trade context for the Murphy pre-emigration life and for the later JJM Sr clothing- sales career (Murphy men were leather-and-cloth tradesmen).
- Ellen (Lyne) Murphy (b. Ardgroom; m. Patrick Murphy 1881; d. Butte 1935)(as printed: Ellen Murphy formerly Lyne)role: mother · family confidence: 100 certain
residence: Ardgroom
4th primary-source confirmation of maiden name Lyne.
Also mentioned
- Dora Neill · informant_present_at_birth
Informant; qualification written Present at the Birth, residence Ardgroom. Possibly the attending midwife, an inference the register does not state.
- Charles Harrison · registrar
Same Charles Harrison who registered the 1881 Patrick Murphy + Ellen Lyne marriage. Continuing Kilcatherine-district service.
- Helen Foley · cert_reissue_officer_2013
Modern Authorised Officer who reissued the cert reproduction 8 Nov 2013.
Places
- Ardgroom (village + RC Chapel) (primary)
- Kilcatherine Registrar's District (primary)
- Castletownbere, County Cork (primary)
- County Cork (primary)
- Ireland (primary)
Themes
Story threads
Tags
Related sources
- 1881-02-13 — Marriage Returns, Superintendent Registrar's District of Castletown — Marriage of Patrick Murphy and Ellen Lyne, 13 Feb 1881, Ardgroom
- 1883-07-29 — Parish of Eyeries, Diocese of Kerry — Register of Baptisms — Birth and Baptismal Certificate — James Murphy (born 26 July 1883, baptized 29 July 1883)
- 1912-04-23 — Montana Bureau of Vital Statistics, Certificate of Death — Patrick J. Murphy death certificate — d. 23 April 1912, 4:30 PM, Warm Springs MT State Hospital, age 56
Transcription
Dotted underlines mark key terms on first mention — hover or tab to one for a reference note. The wording is the source’s own.
Open questions
- Birth-date discrepancy (2 Aug civil vs 26 July baptism) needs resolution by re-checking the original Eyeries parish baptismal register. If the parish register actually says 2 August (with the 1971 cert being a transcription error), the discrepancy resolves; if the parish register itself says 26 July, then the discrepancy is original (parish vs state) and the civil cert should be treated as more authoritative.
- The 1971 baptismal cert + the 2013 birth cert + the GEDCOM + the 1900 census + the 1918 WW1 draft + the 1958 JJM Jr resume — each of these has either 26 July or no date. Worth a back-pass to align all the date-attribution notes once the parish-register original is re-checked.