16 Jun 1920: AOH Division No. 1 minutes: committee of three, 'Bros. Murphy. Gribben, Fr O'Shea', to arrange a social for the other Irish organizations

Ancient Order of Hibernians, Division No. 1 (Butte): minute book · Butte, Silver Bow County, Montana · 1920-06-16

society minutesprimary focus

Summary

Photograph IMG_7577 of the minute book of the Ancient Order of Hibernians (Division No. 1, Butte), held by the Butte-Silver Bow Public Archives. Pages in the photograph: 374 (left page, full), 375 (right page, full, ending "over") Date: 9 Jun 1920 (written "June 9. 1920", p. 374); 16 Jun 1920 (written "June 16 1920", p. 375) Officers signing: Ed Connolly, Rec. Secretary (p. 374). Vice President M. J. McDonough in the chair at both meetings. P. 375 continues past the leaf, marked "over". Topics: Irish Bond Drive — over $51,000.00 subscribed in Butte; St. Patrick's Day committee report to the Irish Bond Drive committee of Silver Bow County, and dissolution of that committee; annual picnic committee (Brown, Gribben, Boyle, Caplis, Sullivan); National Treasurer's inquiry about insurance / life insurance on members, and a unanimous view against insuring the Division's membership at this time; joint picnic with all the Irish societies in the county, to be held not later than July 25th; Fr. Connolly's return to Butte from a recent visit to Ireland; the invitation to Archbishop Mannix to visit Butte on his way to New York, and his inability to come because tickets for passage were already placed; a social in the Hall for the other Irish organizations; insurance at the National Convention (San Francisco; next convention Detroit). James J. Murphy in this source (passages read from the image, dossier register of 26 Sept 2026): - 16 Jun 1920: On 16 Jun 1920 a Brother Murphy was named with John Gribben and Fr. Jas. O'Shea to Division No. 1's committee of three to arrange a social in Hibernia Hall for the members of the other Irish organizations, after Fr. O'Shea proposed that Fr. Connolly, a member of the division just back from Ireland, address them. [probable] - 16 Jun 1920: On 16 Jun 1920 a Brother Murphy argued in Division No. 1 that a national insurance scheme would be good for the order in Silver Bow County and in the nation at large, after the division had been asked by the National Treasurer (9 Jun 1920) whether the Montana organization insured its members. [probable] The whole-page transcription is a single Sonnet reading of 13 Sept 2026 and has not been proofed against the image; quote James's passages from the readings listed above.

In its time

People

Places

Themes

Story threads

Tags

Transcription
transcription: complete · confidence medium
# IMG_7577 - **Type:** handwritten minutes - **Book page number(s) visible:** 374 (left page, full), 375 (right page, full, ending "over") - **Meeting date(s):** 9 Jun 1920 (written "June 9. 1920", p. 374); 16 Jun 1920 (written "June 16 1920", p. 375) - **Place / body:** CentervilleButte: companies, unions & placesCentervilleThe hillside neighbourhood between uptown Butte and Walkerville, built among the mine yards and home to many Irish and Cornish mining families.More in Key terms →, Mont. — AOHIrish societiesAncient Order of Hiberniansin America from 1836The largest Irish Catholic fraternal order in America: sick and death benefits for members, St. Patrick’s Day parades, and steady support for Irish nationalism.More in Key terms → Division No. 1 - **Officers signing:** Ed Connolly, Rec. Secretary (p. 374). Vice President M. J. McDonough in the chair at both meetings. P. 375 continues past the leaf, marked "over". - **Murphy mentions:** - "Bros. Murphy" — p. 375, New Business: "Carried - Bros. Murphy. Gribben, Fr O'Shea, Committee -" (named to the committee of three to arrange a social in the Hall and invite the other Irish organizations, arising from Fr. Connolly's return from Ireland / the Archbishop Mannix invitation) - "Bro Murphy" — p. 375, under Insurance: "Bro Murphy. also. spoke. arguing that. Insurance Nationally would be good for. the Organization in Silver Bow. and also in the Nation at large" - **Other key names present:** **John Gribben — yes** (p. 374, named to the annual picnic committee; p. 375, named with Murphy and Fr. O'Shea to the social committee and speaking on Insurance). No J. J. Lynch on these pages. No Chas H. Gallagher; no J. J. O'Meara; no T. J. McCarthy; no James Connolly (Ed Connolly is Rec. Sec.). Others: Vice President M. J. McDonough, Bro Boyle, Bro Brown, Bro Lavelle, Bro Caplis, Bro Sullivan, the National Treasurer, the State President, Fr. Jas. O'Shea, Fr. Connolly, Archbishop Mannix. - **Topics:** Irish Bond Drive — over $51,000.00 subscribed in Butte; St. Patrick's Day committee report to the Irish Bond Drive committee of Silver Bow County, and dissolution of that committee; annual picnic committee (Brown, Gribben, Boyle, Caplis, Sullivan); National Treasurer's inquiry about insurance / life insurance on members, and a unanimous view against insuring the Division's membership at this time; joint picnic with all the Irish societies in the county, to be held not later than July 25th; Fr. Connolly's return to Butte from a recent visit to Ireland; the invitation to **Archbishop Mannix** to visit Butte on his way to New York, and his inability to come because tickets for passage were already placed; a social in the Hall for the other Irish organizations; insurance at the National Convention (San Francisco; next convention Detroit). ## Transcription ### Left page — 374 374 Centerville Mont June 9. 1920 Regular meeting of Division #1 called to order [interlined: The minutes of previous meeting were read & approved] at 8.30 P.m. by Vice President M. McDonough Roll call of Officers 5 present Propositions for membership none Reports on candidates " Initiation " " Communications & Correspondence " Bills & Claims " Sick Committee no report Special Committees Bro Boyle McDonough & Brown reported progress on behalf of the Irish Bond Drive committee announcing that over $51,000.00 had been subscribed in Butte Bro Brown also reported that the St Patrick's Day committee had submitted their report to the Irish Bond drive committee of Silver Bow County and it was accepted with thanks. Bro Lavelle then moved that the report be accepted with the thanks of the Division. And placed on file. and the [struck: members of the] committee be dissolved New business. Bro Brown urged the Division to take action on the annual picnic And moved that a committee [interlined: of 5] be appointed, this was seconded and carried & the president named Bros Brown Gibben [Gribben]. Boyle. Caplis & Sullivan to act on this Committee. Bro Caplis read a communicication from the National Treasurer asking for information as to whether the organization in Mont had Insurance on its members, or whether they desired to take out Life Insurance. Bro Brown moved that the communication be brought before the meeting for discussion, this was Seconded and carried. [margin: A Motion was made & Seconded that the State President answer this letter as he sees fit.] An interesting [struck: debate] then took place by many of the members present on the question of Insurance. the opinion was unanimous that it would be Unwise to take action along these lines of Insuring the Membership of this division at this time. Bro Brown also refered to [interlined: the proposed joint reunion] of the Anaconda & this Division & Bro Caplis suggested that it would be well to combine the reunion with the annual picnic Receipts $23.15 Disbursments None Ed Connolly Rec. Secretary ### Right page — 375 375 Centerville Mont. June 16 1920 Regular meeting of Division #1. called to order at 8.20 P.m. by Vice Pres. McDonough. Minutes of previous meeting read and approved - Roll call of officers - 3 present. Propositions for membership - none. Reports on candidates. none Initiations none Communications & Correspondence none Bills & Claims none. Committee on Sick none Special Committees: a report. was. read from the committee. appointed last. meeting night. to determine whether we would hold [struck: a picnic] this year. recommending that we do. hold a picnic in conjunction with some. or all the Irish societies in the County. and further that. it be held. at. a date not. later than July. 25th Moved & seconded that the report. be received and that the. committee - thro the secretary ask the other Irish Societies in the County to appoint committees to meet with. this committee and arrange for holding a picnic under their joint auspices. at. a date as. early as. can be arranged, Carried New Business : Fr. Jas. O'Shea. spoke at. some length. referring - to the return to Butte of Fr. Connolly. a member of this Division from a recent. visit to Ireland. He. suggested that we invite the other organizations. to the hall next. wednesday night and have. Fr. Connolly address us. in social session. He. also. refered to the recent. invitation sent. to archbishop mannix to visit Butte on his way. to N.y. ark [N.Y. etc.]. He was advised that due to the fact. that the tickets. for. passage. across. the Water were placed he would not be able to visit Butte. Moved & Seconded that a committee of three. be appointed to arrange. [struck: for] to hold a social in this Hall. and invite the members of the other Irish organizations to be present. - the date to be held. for further detail - Carried - Bros. Murphy. Gribben, Fr O'Shea, Committee - Insurance :- Bros. Gribben and Fr O'Shea spoke under this head. Fr O'Shea voicing the opinion that Insurance was. [voted?] in the opinion of the National Convention - at. San Francisco - and would come forward at. the next. Convention Detroit. Bro Murphy. also. spoke. arguing that. Insurance Nationally. would be good for. the Organization in Silver Bow. and also in the Nation. at large - over ## Passages re-read from the image (Opus, 26 Sept 2026) From the dossier register, `research/docs/jjm-dossier-2026-09-26/register/`. These readings, not the whole-page text above, are the ones to quote. - **div1_1920-06-16_minutes_p375_social-committee** (probable; div1-c.yaml): Bros. Murphy > New Business: Fr. Jas. O'Shea. spoke at. some length. referring - to the return to Butte of Fr. Connolly. a member of this Division from a recent. visit to Ireland. He. suggested that we invite the other organizations. to the Hall next. wednesday night and have. Fr. Connolly address us. in social session. He. also. referred to the recent. invitation sent. to archbishop Mannix to visit Butte on his way. to N.Y.[?] [...] Moved & Seconded that a committee of three. be appointed to arrange. [for, struck through] to hold a social in this Hall. and invite the members of the other Irish organizations to be present. - the date to be held. for further detail - Carried - Bros. Murphy. Gribben, Fr O'Shea, Committee - - **div1_1920-06-16_minutes_p375_insurance-speech** (probable; div1-c.yaml): Bro Murphy > Insurance :- Bro[s]. Gribben and Fr O'Shea spoke under this head. Fr O'Shea voicing the opinion that Insurance was. wise[?] in the opinion of the National Convention - at. San Francisco - and would come forward at. the next. Convention Detroit. Bro Murphy. also. spoke. arguing that. Insurance Nationally. would be good for. the Organization in Silver Bow. and also in the Nation. at large - over

Dotted underlines mark key terms on first mention — hover or tab to one for a reference note. The wording is the source’s own.

Source ID: 1920-06-16_aoh-div1-butte_minutes-p375

Reference: AOH Division No. 1 (Butte) minute book, book p. 375, meeting of 16 Jun 1920 (photo IMG_7577)

Accessed by lukedmurphy on 2026-09-11.