ST. PATRICK'S DAY USHERED IN WITH A GREAT BANQUET
The Butte Miner, Butte, 1914-03-17, p.1
Page image
Full page scan, 2,848 × 3,595 pixels. The insets below are the parts of this page that belong to the clipping; click one to jump to it on the page.
headlineHeadline
reportThe article, column 1 of 2
reportThe article, column 2 of 2
name as printed"James N. Murphy"
Summary
Sub-head: "Irish-Americans of Mining Metropolis and Their Guests Have Delightful Time at Silver Bow Club — Splendid Addresses on Topics Having to Do With Annual Observance Are Delivered — Plans Have Been Made for Entertainment Today." Front-page Butte Miner report on the St. Patrick's Eve banquet at the Silver Bow club, March 16 1914. "Truly patriotic was the meeting of Irish-Americans last night at the Silver Bow club on the occasion of their annual celebration of St. Patrick's day." Senator H. A. Gallwey presided as toastmaster. **Justice W. L. Holloway** as first speaker, on "The President." **W. W. Walsworth spoke feelingly on "Our Country."** John H. Tolan, "a prominent Missoula attorney," talked about "Montana." **Attorney T. J. Walker pleased all with a discussion on the theme of the evening, "The Irish-American."** Attorney W. B. Rodgers closed the program with "St. Patrick's Day." Menu: Martini cocktail, cream of tomato soup, cheese straws, celery, salted almonds, olives, sauterne, crab a la Newberg, Lacrima Christi, broiled tenderloin steak with sauce Bernaise, new potatoes, fresh asparagus, punch creme de menthe, grapefruit salad, champagne wafers, cheese, apple pie a la mode, crackers, cigars, coffee, cigarettes. Program (as printed): - Toastmaster — Senator H. A. Gallwey (with a Goldsmith quotation, "Deserted Village") - "The President" — Hon. W. L. Holloway, associate justice supreme court - National airs — Orchestra - "Our Country" — W. W. Walsworth - Song, "I'll Take You Home Again, Kathleen" — James N. Murphy - "Montana" — John H. Tolan - "Montana" — Orchestra - **"The Irish-American" — Thomas J. Walker** - Song, "The Minstrel Boy" — Ed Lee - "St. Patrick's Day" — W. B. Rodgers - "The Star Spangled Banner" — Ensemble The page prints Justice Holloway's address ("Holloway's Remarks"), not Walker's, in full on page one: "This might well be termed an age of universal criticism," said Justice Holloway. It runs the rest of both columns, on the president, the constitution and party government, ending "Continued on Page Two—Col. One." ARCHIVE SIGNIFICANCE. **(a) RESOLVES the OCR question from the 1914-03-18 clipping** — the "James W. Walker" / "Thomas J. Walker" question is now resolved: **Thomas J. Walker** is the attorney who gave the Irish-American speech, the night before the AOH afternoon exercises JJM presided over. The two clippings bracket St. Patrick's 1914 (eve banquet → next-day exercises); Walker speaks at the eve banquet, JJM presides over the next day. (b) The Silver Bow club banquet is now confirmed as an annual fixture across 1911-1914 (the 1911-03-17 clipping shows the same format). (c) Justice W. L. Holloway is the Montana Supreme Court justice and a recurring speaker. TRANSCRIPTION NOTE. The page-one text is fully legible and transcribed (21 Oct 2026). Walker's address is not printed on page one; if the paper printed it, it would be on the page-two continuation, which the archive does not hold.
In its time
Narrative
Irish-Americans of Butte and their guests mark the eve of St. Patrick's Day with a banquet in the dining room of the Silver Bow club, Senator H. A. Gallway presiding as toastmaster. Justice W. L. Holloway speaks on "The President," tracing the office from Washington to Wilson; W. W. Walsworth on "Our Country"; Missoula attorney John H. Tolan on "Montana"; and Thomas J. Walker on "The Irish-Americans," with songs from Ed Lee and remarks on St. Patrick's Day by W. F. Hodgson. [transcription partial — OCR-degraded; several program entries and the close of Holloway's address unclear]
- “He told of the presidents from Washington to Wilson, emphasizing that all is not "milk and honey" in the White house.”
- “Most of the criticism of our public men is fully justified, but much more of it has no foundation whatever.”
AI-generated (claude-opus-5). Verify against the transcription before quoting.
People
- role: implied attendee aoh county president · family confidence: 50 candidate
JJM is not explicitly named in the legible portion of this clipping. The next-day clipping (1914-03-18) has him presiding over the afternoon exercises as AOH county president; he was very likely at the eve banquet too as one of the principal Irish-American organisers. The full attendee list would be on the page-2 continuation not in this clip. Held at the same confidence as elsewhere; can be revised on a page-vision back-pass.
- Thomas J. Walker (Butte attorney; Silver Bow county attorney 1912)(as printed: Thomas J. Walker)role: speaker the irish americans · family confidence: 0 not family
- Harry A. Gallwey (state senator for Silver Bow; toastmaster of the 1914 St. Patrick's banquet)(as printed: Senator H. A. Gallway)role: toastmaster · family confidence: 0 not family
- W. W. Walsworth (of The Anaconda Standard)(as printed: W. W. Walsworth)role: speaker our country · family confidence: 0 not family
- Ed Lee (Butte singer at Irish events, 1911-1914)(as printed: Ed Lee)role: minstrel boy song · family confidence: 0 not family
Also mentioned
- Justice W. L. Holloway · speaker_executive_justice_supreme_court
= the Hon. William L. Holloway who toasted 'The Irish-Americans' at the 1911 Silver Bow Club banquet — three years on now characterized as Justice and Executive Justice Supreme Court.
- W. B. Rodgers · st_patricks_day_speaker
Attorney; closed the program. Printed W. B. Rodgers in the body and the program (an earlier reading had W. F. Hodgson).
Places
- Butte, Montana (primary)
Themes
Story threads
Tags
Source type
news_item, public_meeting_report
Related sources
Transcription
Dotted underlines mark key terms on first mention — hover or tab to one for a reference note. The wording is the source’s own.
Open questions
- Page-2 continuation ("Continued on Page Two — Col. One") likely contains the full attendee list. Worth fetching.
- On the back-pass, update the 1914-03-18 clipping's open_question on "James W. Walker" to mark it as RESOLVED via cross-ref to this clipping.